How to Choose the Right Puzzle for Someone With Dementia
This post contains affiliate links for Completing the Puzzle. If you make a purchase using my affiliate link or discount code, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products and services that I genuinely believe provide value, and all opinions expressed are my own.
As both an occupational therapist and a former family caregiver, I have seen firsthand how meaningful activities can help create moments of connection for individuals living with dementia.
When my mother was living with Lewy body dementia, I learned that success was not measured by completing a task perfectly. Success was measured by moments of engagement, enjoyment, confidence, and connection.
Puzzles can be a wonderful activity for many individuals living with dementia. They can support attention, visual perception, problem-solving, and fine motor skills. More importantly, they can create opportunities for families to spend meaningful time together.
However, choosing the right puzzle is important. The goal isn’t to challenge someone to the point of frustration. The goal is to help them experience success.
Start With Success, Not Difficulty
One of the most common mistakes families make is purchasing puzzles based on what their loved one used to enjoy rather than what they can comfortably manage today.
A person who once completed 1,000-piece puzzles may no longer find those puzzles enjoyable as dementia progresses.
When a puzzle becomes too difficult, it can lead to frustration, anxiety, withdrawal, and reduced participation.
Instead, look for a puzzle that allows your loved one to feel successful.
Ask yourself:
- Can they easily see the image?
- Can they comfortably manipulate the pieces?
- Can they identify matching colors or patterns?
- Do they appear engaged rather than frustrated?
If the answer is yes, you’re likely choosing an appropriate puzzle.
Consider Piece Size
Large-piece puzzles can be an excellent choice for someone living with dementia.
Larger pieces may be easier to see and grasp, create less visual clutter, and make the activity more manageable for someone who also has arthritis or decreased hand strength.
Puzzle rental services can also be a convenient way to try different puzzle styles and piece counts without purchasing a large collection.
Choose Familiar Images
Familiarity matters.
Consider puzzle images featuring:
- Nature scenes
- Pets
- Flowers
- Birds
- Vintage automobiles
- Landscapes
- Hometown landmarks
- Personal hobbies and interests
Whenever possible, choose images that connect with your loved one’s interests and long-term memories.
Highly abstract or visually busy designs may be more difficult to process and could make the activity feel overwhelming.
Match the Puzzle to Current Abilities
Dementia affects each person differently, so there isn’t one puzzle size or piece count that will work for everyone.
Earlier Stages
Some individuals may continue enjoying larger puzzles with more detailed images and complete them independently.
Middle Stages
A puzzle with fewer, larger pieces and a clear image may be easier to manage. Working alongside a family member can also make the activity more enjoyable.
Later Stages
Consider simpler matching activities, wooden puzzles, puzzles with fewer large pieces, or completing an activity together.
Remember that abilities can also vary from day to day.
Rather than focusing strictly on the stage of dementia, pay attention to how the person is responding to the activity that day.
Watch for Signs of Frustration
A puzzle is no longer serving its purpose if it causes distress.
Watch for signs such as pushing pieces away, verbal frustration, increased agitation, repeatedly walking away, or saying, “I can’t do this.”
When you notice these signs, consider simplifying the activity rather than encouraging the person to keep pushing through it.
The goal is meaningful engagement—not completion.
Adapt the Activity
This is where some simple occupational therapy strategies can make a big difference.
Try:
- Completing some of the border pieces beforehand
- Sorting pieces by color
- Working on one small section at a time
- Using a puzzle board
- Providing encouragement without taking over
- Limiting the number of pieces visible at one time
Sometimes changing the activity just a little is enough to turn frustration into success.
Focus on Connection
One of the greatest benefits of puzzles isn’t necessarily cognitive stimulation.
It’s connection.
Sitting together, sharing stories, reminiscing, laughing, and working toward a common goal can create meaningful moments for both the person living with dementia and their caregiver.
Sometimes the finished puzzle matters far less than the time spent together.
Final Thoughts
The best puzzle isn’t necessarily the most difficult puzzle.
The best puzzle is the one that allows your loved one to participate, experience success, and enjoy meaningful engagement.
By focusing on current abilities rather than past abilities, families can continue using puzzles as a source of enjoyment, confidence, and connection throughout the dementia journey.
Because success isn’t measured by how many pieces are completed.
It’s measured by the smiles, conversations, and moments shared along the way.
Looking for Dementia-Friendly Puzzles?
Finding the right puzzle can make all the difference. If you’re looking for a variety of puzzles with different images and piece counts without purchasing new puzzles each time, I recommend exploring Completing the Puzzle, a monthly jigsaw puzzle rental service.
I appreciate that families can rotate puzzles regularly, helping keep activities fresh and engaging while reducing the cost and clutter of owning dozens of puzzles.
→Explore Completing the Puzzle using my affiliate link and use my affiliate code at checkout: PUZZLEOT
Looking for Additional Support?
If you’re helping a loved one living with dementia, choosing the right activity is only part of the journey.
I created my Dementia Activity Planner to help caregivers plan meaningful activities, track engagement, and create more successful moments.
The planner includes simple tools to help you plan activities with purpose, track which activities work best, monitor engagement and mood, and create more meaningful moments together.
Continue Reading
If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy:
Why Jigsaw Puzzles May Support Brain Health and Healthy Aging
Learn how jigsaw puzzles engage multiple skills and how they can be incorporated into meaningful activities throughout adulthood.
About Kimberly
Kimberly Orlando, MOT, OTR/L, is an occupational therapist with more than 25 years of clinical experience and a former family caregiver to her mother, who lived with Lewy body dementia for six years. Through Sunny by Kimberly, she shares practical, OT-informed resources to help caregivers support safety, independence, meaningful activity, and everyday quality of life.
Disclaimer: The information shared by Sunny by Kimberly is for educational purposes only and is based on my experience as an occupational therapist and family caregiver. It is not intended to replace individualized medical, occupational therapy, or healthcare advice. Always consult your healthcare provider regarding your specific situation.
